Whitesnake – Slip of the Tongue: One Guitarist, Two Eras

Whitesnake stood at their commercial zenith in 1987, with their self-titled album selling over 8 million copies in the US alone and peaking at number two on the Billboard 200. But John Sykes, the architect of that success, was fired just before the album’s release.

For the 1989 follow-up, David Coverdale chose a guitarist with completely different DNA: Steve Vai. One band, two guitarists, and a 180-degree shift in musical identity. Slip of the Tongue stands as a fascinating case study in how a single guitarist can redefine a band’s sound.

---

The Unfinished Business

After Vivian Campbell departed in late 1988 due to musical differences, Coverdale and Adrian Vandenberg retreated to Lake Tahoe to concentrate on writing the next album. Vandenberg co-wrote every song and was fully prepared to record all guitar parts.

But just before the recording sessions began, he sustained a severe wrist injury from isometric exercises designed for pianists. Unable to even grip a guitar neck, Vandenberg had to step away from the studio, watching helplessly as the songs he’d written remained unrecorded.

The label wouldn’t wait. With studio time already booked and Christmas season release pressure mounting, Coverdale had to find a replacement guitarist.

---

Enter the Virtuoso

Coverdale’s choice was Steve Vai. Having worked with Frank Zappa and David Lee Roth, Vai was one of the most technically accomplished guitarists of the era. Coverdale made his decision after seeing Vai’s performance in the 1986 film Crossroads. After three days of persuasion, Vai joined the band, with Coverdale promising him creative freedom and even proposing the simultaneous release of Vai’s solo album Passion & Warfare alongside the Whitesnake record.

What Vai brought wasn’t just technical prowess. He used the Ibanez Universe, the world’s first mass-produced seven-string electric guitar, throughout the album. In 1989, the full-scale adoption of a seven-string guitar on a hard rock album was unprecedented. The instrument’s additional low B string created a massive, metallic sound. But this was the polar opposite of the bluesy sensibility Vandenberg had envisioned.

---

The Sykes Legacy vs. The Vai Revolution

John Sykes’ guitar work on the 1987 album was powerful yet restrained. His playing, which layered metal aggression over blues rock foundations, found its perfect expression in “Still of the Night.” Vai’s approach, by contrast, bordered on the avant-garde. On “Kittens Got Claws,” he mimicked cat meows on guitar and showcased complex tapping and sweep picking techniques. Same band, completely different philosophy.

Vandenberg later reflected, “Vai’s flamboyant guitar playing was somewhat inappropriate. A more bluesy approach would have suited the album better.” Vai himself reportedly apologized to Vandenberg, admitting, “My ego was inflated at the time. I was too showy.” But the music was already recorded, and the album emerged with a sound completely divorced from the John Sykes era.

---

Production Nightmare

The production process was equally chaotic. Geffen Records A&R executive John Kalodner pushed hard for Mike Clink, who had successfully produced Guns N’ Roses’ Appetite for Destruction. But the sessions with Clink proved problematic. When Keith Olsen, who had been booked 18 months in advance, finally came on board, he discovered a critical flaw.

Olsen’s testimony is revealing: “When I first listened to the tracks, I said, ‘Wow, all these tracks are in the key of A. Don’t you have any other songs in any other keys?'” The entire album had been recorded in the same key. Olsen had to change keys, adjust tempos, and re-record substantial portions. Though both Clink and Olsen received co-production credits, this chaos contributed to the album’s lack of cohesion.

---

Coverdale’s Breaking Point

Coverdale himself was reaching his limit. The 1987-1988 tour had devastated his body. Chronic sinusitis and a deviated septum made normal breathing difficult, necessitating surgery. “There was a 50/50 chance I wouldn’t be able to sing in the same style again,” he recalled, revealing the severity of his condition.

In April 1988, he also underwent surgery for a herniated disc. Relying on the powerful narcotic painkiller Percodan during recording, he called “Judgement Day” his “Percodan riff.” The song was simultaneously a jab at Robert Plant. The majestic riff, reminiscent of Led Zeppelin’s “Kashmir,” embodied Coverdale’s complex feelings toward Plant.

---

The Album: Ambition and Identity Crisis

Released on November 7, 1989, Slip of the Tongue wasn’t a commercial failure. It reached number ten on both the Billboard 200 and UK Albums Chart, earning platinum certification in the US. It sold 1.2 million copies in just four days. But compared to the previous album’s 8 million sales, this represented a clear decline.

The re-recording of “Fool for Your Loving” aimed to replicate the success of 1987’s re-recorded “Here I Go Again,” but original fans criticized it as “having had its soul stripped out.” “Judgement Day,” which Coverdale wanted as the first single, was vetoed by the label—a decision he would deeply regret.

“The Deeper the Love” achieved the album’s highest chart position at number 28 on the Billboard Hot 100, but couldn’t compare to the previous album’s “Is This Love” (number 2).

“Now You’re Gone,” a ballad utilizing tempo shifts, explored the emptiness following a relationship’s end. The single version was handled by Chris Lord-Alge and served as the final release from Slip of the Tongue.

---

Critical Divide

Critics were harsh. Rolling Stone’s Jonathan Gold mocked Whitesnake as evolving “from Deep Purple knockoffs to Led Zeppelin knockoffs, and now Def Leppard knockoffs.” The Los Angeles Times called it a “primordial soup of arena-rock cliches,” awarding it 1.5 out of 5 stars. Loss of identity, excessive technical display, and departure from blues roots were the main criticisms.

But the metal press responded differently. Kerrang! ranked the album at number 11 on their best rock albums of 1989, and it hit number one in Finland—Whitesnake’s only chart-topping album anywhere. The fanbase was divided. The gulf between old fans longing for the John Sykes era and new fans thrilled by Steve Vai’s technique remained unbridged.

---

The Tour and the End

The Liquor & Poker World Tour, which kicked off on February 2, 1990, was the band’s largest undertaking. They headlined the Monsters of Rock festival at Castle Donington on August 18 before 70,000 people—a performance later released as Live at Donington 1990 in 2011. Onstage, Vai and Vandenberg performed together as dual guitarists, but their stylistic differences remained stark.

September 26, 1990, at Tokyo’s Nippon Budokan. On the tour’s final night, Coverdale announced the band’s hiatus after the show. Extreme burnout, divorce proceedings from Tawny Kitaen, and disillusionment with the glam metal image were the reasons. Whitesnake’s 1980s came to an end.

---

Legacy: When One Guitarist Changes Everything

Thirty years later, in 2019, the album was reissued as a seven-disc box set and reached number seven on the UK Rock & Metal chart. Time has granted this album a new assessment. Steve Vai’s introduction of the seven-string guitar became a pioneering example of the instrument that would be fully embraced by 1990s nu-metal bands, and his avant-garde approach is now considered “groundbreaking.”

But core questions remain. What if Adrian Vandenberg hadn’t been injured? What if John Sykes hadn’t been fired? Slip of the Tongue stands as perfect evidence of how a single guitarist defines a band’s identity. John Sykes’ 1987 album made Whitesnake a stadium band. Steve Vai’s 1989 album pushed them into the future while simultaneously forcing a break from the past.

Two guitarists, two eras. This album, which once divided the fanbase, has endured as a valuable case study in how one guitarist can redefine a band.

More on Whitesnake

• [Music Video Collection] Whitesnake: History & Playlist